{ "entry_id": "TSP-ENT-000007", "slug": "rock", "url_path": "/types-symbols/rock/", "canonical_name": "Rock", "entry_classifications": [ "METAPHOR", "SYMBOL" ], "modules": [ "CHRISTOLOGICAL_TYPES", "SPIRIT_IMAGERY" ], "aliases": [ { "alias_text": "ROCK (shelter)", "alias_type": "POINTER" } ], "legacy_present": true, "legacy_raw_wording_public": false, "senses": [ { "sense_id": "TSP-SNS-000013", "label": "The spiritual Rock identified with Christ", "classification": "METAPHOR", "definition": "Paul states that Israel drank from the spiritual Rock that followed them, and the Rock was Christ.", "not_always": "This does not make every biblical rock a symbol of Christ.", "scope_note": "The explicit statement is controlled by 1 Corinthians 10 and its wilderness-warning context.", "claims": [ { "claim_id": "TSP-CLM-000013", "statement": "Paul explicitly identifies the spiritual Rock in the wilderness pattern with Christ.", "asserted_classifications": [ "METAPHOR", "TYPE" ], "type_kinds": [ "EVENT_TYPE" ], "evidence_grade": 1, "grade_basis": "G1_EXPLICIT_BIBLICAL_INTERPRETATION", "status": "ESTABLISHED", "public_wording_class": "SCRIPTURE_EXPLICITLY_IDENTIFIES", "scope_limitation": "The explicit identification concerns the spiritual Rock in Paul's wilderness argument; it does not establish every rock as Christ or every rock detail as a type.", "strongest_alternative_explanation": null, "residual_uncertainty": null, "theological_intersections": [ "CHRISTOLOGY", "PNEUMATOLOGY" ], "scripture_references": [ { "passage_ref_id": "TSP-PAS-000025", "osis_start": "1Cor.10.1", "osis_end": "1Cor.10.11", "display_label": "1 Corinthians 10:1-11", "versification_system": "ENGLISH_STANDARD" }, { "passage_ref_id": "TSP-PAS-000024", "osis_start": "Exod.17.1", "osis_end": "Exod.17.7", "display_label": "Exodus 17:1-7", "versification_system": "ENGLISH_STANDARD" } ], "source_citations": [ { "source_id": "TSP-SRC-000008", "author_editor": null, "title": "Canonical Scripture: MT/LXX/NA28 with NET/ESV comparison", "publication_data": "Text loci verified for TSP-S0F Batch 2", "locator": null, "verification_level": "V4_QUOTATION_VERIFIED", "source_function": [ "CANONICAL_AUTHORITY", "TEXT_ESTABLISHMENT" ], "locator_targets": [] }, { "source_id": "TSP-SRC-000011", "author_editor": "Eric C. Redmond", "title": "1 Corinthians", "publication_data": "The Gospel Coalition Bible Commentary", "locator": "https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/commentary/1-corinthians/", "verification_level": "V3_CLAIM_VERIFIED", "source_function": [ "SCHOLARLY_ARGUMENT" ], "locator_targets": [ { "kind": "EXTERNAL_URL", "target": "https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/commentary/1-corinthians/" } ] } ], "s8_wording_provenance": null } ] }, { "sense_id": "TSP-SNS-000014", "label": "Struck rock as crucifixion plus water as Spirit through Christ death", "classification": "TYPE", "definition": "The legacy proposal combines rock-striking with Christ crucified and water-flow with the Holy Spirit on the basis of Christ's death.", "not_always": "John 7 identifies living-water imagery with the Spirit, but does not identify Exodus rock-water with the Spirit through Christ's death.", "scope_note": "Treat the detailed construction as unestablished unless a canonical text makes the combined mapping.", "claims": [ { "claim_id": "TSP-CLM-000014", "statement": "The detailed proposal that the struck rock separately encodes Christ crucified and its water encodes the Holy Spirit flowing specifically on the basis of his death lacks sufficient canonical control.", "asserted_classifications": [ "TYPE", "SYMBOL" ], "type_kinds": [ "EVENT_TYPE" ], "evidence_grade": 7, "grade_basis": "G7_INSUFFICIENT_BIBLICAL_EVIDENCE", "status": "INSUFFICIENT_BIBLICAL_EVIDENCE", "public_wording_class": "INSUFFICIENT_BIBLICAL_EVIDENCE", "scope_limitation": "Retain Paul's explicit Rock-Christ identification and John's explicit living-water/Spirit interpretation separately; do not fuse them into a detailed Exodus code without textual warrant.", "strongest_alternative_explanation": "1 Corinthians 10 identifies Christ as the Rock; John 7 separately interprets living water as Spirit imagery. The two facts do not by themselves establish the legacy compound mapping.", "residual_uncertainty": null, "theological_intersections": [ "CHRISTOLOGY", "PNEUMATOLOGY", "ATONEMENT" ], "scripture_references": [ { "passage_ref_id": "TSP-PAS-000025", "osis_start": "1Cor.10.1", "osis_end": "1Cor.10.11", "display_label": "1 Corinthians 10:1-11", "versification_system": "ENGLISH_STANDARD" }, { "passage_ref_id": "TSP-PAS-000026", "osis_start": "John.7.37", "osis_end": "John.7.39", "display_label": "John 7:37-39", "versification_system": "ENGLISH_STANDARD" } ], "source_citations": [ { "source_id": "TSP-SRC-000009", "author_editor": null, "title": "Legacy Symbols & Types list supplied for TSP project", "publication_data": "User-supplied legacy corpus", "locator": null, "verification_level": "V4_QUOTATION_VERIFIED", "source_function": [ "INTERPRETIVE_HISTORY" ], "locator_targets": [] }, { "source_id": "TSP-SRC-000008", "author_editor": null, "title": "Canonical Scripture: MT/LXX/NA28 with NET/ESV comparison", "publication_data": "Text loci verified for TSP-S0F Batch 2", "locator": null, "verification_level": "V4_QUOTATION_VERIFIED", "source_function": [ "CANONICAL_AUTHORITY", "TEXT_ESTABLISHMENT" ], "locator_targets": [] }, { "source_id": "TSP-SRC-000011", "author_editor": "Eric C. Redmond", "title": "1 Corinthians", "publication_data": "The Gospel Coalition Bible Commentary", "locator": "https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/commentary/1-corinthians/", "verification_level": "V3_CLAIM_VERIFIED", "source_function": [ "SCHOLARLY_ARGUMENT" ], "locator_targets": [ { "kind": "EXTERNAL_URL", "target": "https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/commentary/1-corinthians/" } ] }, { "source_id": "TSP-SRC-000012", "author_editor": "D. A. Carson", "title": "Streams of Living Water", "publication_data": "The Gospel Coalition", "locator": "https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/article/streams-living-water/", "verification_level": "V3_CLAIM_VERIFIED", "source_function": [ "SCHOLARLY_ARGUMENT" ], "locator_targets": [ { "kind": "EXTERNAL_URL", "target": "https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/article/streams-living-water/" } ] } ], "s8_wording_provenance": null } ] } ], "lexeme_mappings": [ { "lexeme_link_id": "TSP-LEX-000012", "language": "GREEK", "lemma_unicode": "πέτρα", "transliteration": "petra", "strongs_id": "G4073", "owner_tier": "TSP_MAPPING_ONLY", "semantic_domain_ids": [] } ], "canonical_relationships": [ { "canonical_relationship_id": "TSP-S6-R03-P03-REL-0007", "title": "Wilderness Rock — Christological provision correspondence", "canonical_statement": "Paul's wilderness argument draws on the canonical rock-water provision tradition and explicitly identifies the Rock in his inspired correspondence as Christ.", "canonical_action": "MERGE_MEMBER_RELATIONS_PRESERVE_PROVENANCE", "guardrails": [ "Do not force Exodus 17 or Numbers 20 as the sole source.", "Do not literalize 'the Rock was Christ' into material identity.", "Do not evacuate Paul's explicit christological force into mere metaphor." ], "relationship_status": "CONFIRMED_REFINED" } ], "negative_guardrails": [ { "guardrail_id": "TSP-S6-R03-P03-GRD-034", "canonical_relation_status": "NEGATIVE_GUARDRAIL_INSUFFICIENT", "adjudication_outcome": "INSUFFICIENT_BIBLICAL_EVIDENCE", "decision_statement": "No positive canonical type/symbol relationship is promoted beyond the source evidence: The detailed proposal that the struck rock separately encodes Christ crucified and its water encodes the Holy Spirit flowing specifically on the basis of his death lacks sufficient canonical control." }, { "guardrail_id": "TSP-S6-R03-P03-GRD-046", "canonical_relation_status": "EXCLUDED_OR_LIMITED_COMPONENT_OF_SPLIT_CONCEPT", "adjudication_outcome": "SPLIT_CONCEPT", "decision_statement": "Excluded/limited claim component preserved separately from the positive canonical relationship." } ] }