{
  "id": "dict_001073",
  "term": "concurrence",
  "slug": "concurrence",
  "letter": "C",
  "entry_type": "doctrine",
  "entry_family": "doctrine",
  "tier": 2,
  "aliases": [],
  "short_definition": "Concurrence is the doctrine that God works through created causes without canceling their real action.",
  "simple_one_line": "In Christian theology, concurrence means the doctrine that God works through created causes without canceling their real action.",
  "tooltip_text": "Concurrence is the doctrine that God works through created causes without canceling their real action",
  "lede_intro": "Concurrence is a doctrinal category that should be defined from the passages that establish it, located within the biblical storyline, and stated with clear theological limits.",
  "at_a_glance_definition": "Concurrence is the doctrine that God works through created causes without canceling their real action. This doctrine should be read from the passages that establish it and kept distinct from nearby theological claims.",
  "at_a_glance_key_points": [
    "Concurrence should be defined from the biblical texts that establish it rather than from slogan-level shorthand alone.",
    "It belongs within the larger witness of Scripture and the history of redemption, so related doctrines must be distinguished carefully.",
    "A sound account states what this doctrine affirms, what it does not require, and why it matters for the church's teaching, worship, and discipleship."
  ],
  "description_academic_short": "Concurrence is the doctrine that God works through created causes without canceling their real action. As a doctrine, it should be stated from the passages that establish it and distinguished carefully from adjacent theological claims.",
  "description_academic_full": "Concurrence is the doctrine that God works through created causes without canceling their real action. This doctrine should be defined from the passages that establish it, located within the larger storyline of Scripture, and stated with care in relation to nearby doctrines. Responsible use clarifies what the term affirms, what limits belong to it, and why it matters for the church's teaching, worship, and discipleship.",
  "background_biblical_context": "concurrence belongs to Scripture's teaching on creation, providence, and the order of the world and should be read within that Creator-creature frame. Its background lies in God's creative act, his continuing rule over the world, and the ordered relation between Creator, creatures, and history, so the doctrine is framed by dependence, purpose, and providential government.",
  "background_historical_context": "Historically, discussion of concurrence grew where exegesis of creation and providence met philosophical reflection on being, order, causation, and the dependence of creatures upon God. Patristic and medieval theology, followed by Reformation scholasticism and modern dogmatics, used the term to clarify how the world relates to divine agency without collapsing the integrity of created realities.",
  "background_jewish_ancient_context": null,
  "key_texts_primary": [
    "Ps. 135:6",
    "Eph. 1:11",
    "Prov. 19:21",
    "Isa. 46:9-10",
    "Gen. 45:5-8"
  ],
  "key_texts_secondary": [
    "Gen. 50:20",
    "Isa. 55:10-11",
    "1 Cor. 10:13",
    "Ps. 139:16"
  ],
  "original_language_note": null,
  "original_language_terms": [],
  "theological_significance": "concurrence matters because doctrinal precision in this area protects the church’s speech about God, the gospel, the church, or the last things and helps prevent distortions that spill into neighboring doctrines.",
  "philosophical_explanation": "At the philosophical level, Concurrence tests how theology uses metaphysical distinctions to describe creation without displacing the biblical narrative. The conceptual pressure points are primary and secondary causation, necessity and dependence, temporal becoming and divine eternity, and the status of explanatory models. Used well, the category gives conceptual clarity to dependence and order without turning providence into a rival explanatory mechanism.",
  "interpretive_cautions": "Do not use concurrence as a catch-all doctrinal label that settles questions the relevant texts still require you to argue carefully. Distinguish Creator and creature, primary and secondary causes, and revealed doctrine from philosophical extrapolation, especially where theological language outruns the explicit wording of the text. Define the doctrine carefully enough to preserve real theological boundaries, but do not promote one tradition's preferred ordering of implications into the measure of orthodoxy where the text leaves room for qualified disagreement.",
  "major_views_note": "Concurrence is widely used to articulate creation and providence, but traditions differ over how strongly it should be defined philosophically and how it should be related to biblical language and created causality. The main points of disagreement concern explanatory models, the interpretation of key creation texts, and the relation between God's sovereign decree and the regular patterns of created life.",
  "doctrinal_boundaries": "Concurrence should remain within the Creator-creature distinction and the Bible's teaching on providence, contingency, and creaturely dependence rather than being driven by an abstract metaphysical scheme. It must avoid both deistic distance and determinist flattening, allowing real creaturely causes and historical contingency under God's wise rule. It should therefore affirm real secondary causes under God's wise and sovereign rule. Sound doctrine therefore uses concurrence as a boundary for faithful metaphysical reflection, not as a license to let metaphysics rule revelation.",
  "practical_significance": "Practically, the truth confessed in concurrence belongs in the pulpit, the classroom, the counseling room, and ordinary Christian life. It helps pastors and teachers address questions about the world, causation, order, and dependence without surrendering the Creator-creature distinction. In practice, that strengthens patience, prayer, and ordinary faithfulness under God's unseen rule.",
  "related_entries": [],
  "see_also": [],
  "meta_description": "Concurrence is the doctrine that God works through created causes without canceling their real action.",
  "jsonld_description": "Concurrence is the doctrine that God works through created causes without canceling their real action. This doctrine should be defined from the passages that establish it, located within the larger storyline of Scripture, and stated with care in relation to nearby doctrines. Responsible use clarifies what the term affirms, what limits belong to it, and why it matters for the church's teaching, worship, and discipleship.",
  "source_basis": "scripture-led synthesis",
  "public_url": "/companion-bible-dictionary/bible-dictionary/concurrence/index.html",
  "public_url_absolute": "https://ai-bible-commentary.com/companion-bible-dictionary/bible-dictionary/concurrence/index.html",
  "public_json_url": "/companion-bible-dictionary/data/dictionary/concurrence.json",
  "public_json_url_absolute": "https://ai-bible-commentary.com/companion-bible-dictionary/data/dictionary/concurrence.json",
  "route_mode": "canonical",
  "canonical_id": "dict_001073",
  "canonical_term": "concurrence",
  "canonical_slug": "concurrence",
  "authority_status": "finalized",
  "review_state": "finalized",
  "build_lineage": {
    "workbook": "Bible_Commentary_Companion_Dictionary_Workbook_phase19_10_release_bundle_generated.xlsx",
    "renderer_family": "reconstructed_final_from_live_theme_swap_plus_earlier_polished_renderer",
    "phase": "Phase 19",
    "base_path": "/companion-bible-dictionary",
    "site_domain": "https://ai-bible-commentary.com"
  }
}